“You’re getting into my pet peeve here about tackles because, when they show them in the league, they show this guy makes this many tackles, and Cushing’s 33rd in tackle or something like that,” Phillips said. “But those are press box stats, which really bothers me. We’ve played two games and they count individual tackles, which I think they’re pretty close on, but assists are so far off and the total tackles makes it look like one guys and another guy, it’s like Cush, he’s got two assists. He’s got more of that on our account.
Wade's rant ended something like this:
That’s bothers me that they put out yardage, touchdown passes and all of those things, and those are accurate," Phillips said. "But those assists are not accurate and, if I were a player, I would be upset about it because it looks like, wow, this guy is leading the league in tackling when you may have just as many tackles.”
In a nutshell, league awards are based on statistics and Phillips feels that his players are being shortchanged. Total tackles are being skewed by an inaccurate count of tackle assists.
I did some comparisons with a league-based statistical database (www.statspass.com) to see where the Texans defense and Cushing ranked. The coaches also watch film and grade their own tackles which vary from the pressbox statistics. Those are also included below. Either way, the conclusion is that Phillips has a point. There is a lot of variation in tackle assists between the pressbox and the coaches' review. This affects the total number of tackles which, in turn, ranks the defense and players like Cushing much lower.
- Houston defense ranks 29th (12)
-Cushing ranks 149th (2)
*According to the coaches statistics, the defense has 47 tackle assists. Cushing has 8.
-Houston ranks 29th (93)
-Cushing ranks 32nd (16)
**According to the Texans' coaches statistics, the Texans defense has 98 total tackles and Cushing has 24.
After Sunday’s 30-24 overtime win against the Titans, even Cushing joked about variation in his tackle numbers, which increased from six to eleven in Week 1 after the coaches' review.
“You know I always keep count in my head,” Cushing said. “I know the number is always wrong, but I know what I have. I always get jipped on a couple of tackles, but that’s OK. Yeah, I count. I’m a hungry football player. I want to make all the plays. I want to make all the tackles.”
With such wide discrepancies in tracking tackles, I asked Phillips what the solution should be. He wants either more accuracy or to eliminate assists altogether. He also feels that solo tackles are graded more accurately than assisted ones.
“Well, I don’t have the answer to that unless you go through the film and grade them all,” Phillips said. “I think the other part is don’t give any assists then. Just be accurate on the guy who makes the tackle because it’s so subjective. Like I said, we’ve got guys in the league right now who are way ahead of Cush (ILB Brian Cushing) and I know they’re not because he’s been in on assists when we look at our film.”